×

Impact of value-at-risk models on market stability. (English) Zbl 1401.91590

Summary: Financial institutions around the world use value-at-risk (VaR) models to manage their market risk and calculate their capital requirements under Basel Accords. VaR models, as any other risk management system, are meant to keep financial institutions out of trouble by, among other things, guiding investment decisions within established risk limits so that the viability of a business is not put unduly at risk in a sharp market downturn. However, some researchers have warned that the widespread use of VaR models creates negative externalities in financial markets, as it can feed market instability and result in what has been called endogenous risk, that is, risk caused and amplified by the system itself, rather than being the result of an exogenous shock. This paper aims at analyzing the potential of VaR systems to amplify market disturbances with an agent-based model of fundamentalist and technical traders which manage their risk with a simple VaR model and must reduce their positions when the risk of their portfolio goes above a given threshold. We analyse the impact of the widespread use of VaR systems on different financial instability indicators and confirm that VaR models may induce a particular price dynamics that rises market volatility. These dynamics, which we have called ‘VaR cycles’, take place when a sufficient number of traders reach their VaR limit and are forced to simultaneously reduce their portfolio; the reductions cause a sudden price movement, raise volatility and force even more traders to liquidate part of their positions. The model shows that market is more prone to suffer VaR cycles when investors use a short-term horizon to calculate asset volatility or a not-too-extreme value for their risk threshold.

MSC:

91G80 Financial applications of other theories
91B30 Risk theory, insurance (MSC2010)

Software:

FinTS; QRM

References:

[1] Adrian, T.; Boyarchenko, N., Intermediary leverage cycles and financial stability, (2012), Federal Reserve Bank of New York New York, Staff report No. 567
[2] Adrian, T.; Shin, H., Procyclical leverage and value-at-risk, (2013), Federal Reserve Bank of New York New York, Staff Reports, No. 338
[3] Arthur, W.; Holland, J.; LeBaron, B.; Palmer, R.; Tayler, P., (Asset pricing under endogenous expectations in an artificial stock market, (1996)), SFI Working Paper, 96-12-093
[4] Aymanns, C.; Farmer, J., The dynamics of the leverage cycle, J. Econ. Dyn. Control, 50, 155-179, (2015) · Zbl 1402.91901
[5] Aymanns, C.; Caccioli, F.; Farmer, J.; Tan, V., Taming the basel leverage cycle, J. Financ. Stab., 27, 263-277, (2016)
[6] Financial Stability Review - December 2004, (2004), Bank of England
[7] Beck, T.; De Jonghe, O.; Schepens, G., Bank competition and stability: cross-country heterogeneity, (2011 July), VOX CEPR’s Policy Portal, Retrieved June 14, 2013, from
[8] A review of financial markets events in autumn 1998, (1999), Bank for International Settlements Basilea
[9] Bonenkamp, U., Combining technical and fundamental trading strategies, (2010), Gabler Heidelberg
[10] Bookstaber, R., Using agent-based models for analyzing threats to financial stability, (2012), Office of Financial Research
[11] Bookstaber, R.; Cetina, J.; Feldberg, G.; Flood, M.; Glasserman, P., (Stress tests to promote financial stability: assessing progress and looking to the future, (2013), Office of Financial Research), Working paper 0010
[12] Brock, W.; Hommes, C., Heterogeneous beliefs and routes to chaos in a simple asset pricing model, J. Econ. Dyn. Control, 1235-1274, (1998) · Zbl 0913.90042
[13] Brunnermeier, M.; Pedersen, L., Market liquidity and funding liquidity, Rev. Financ. Stud., 22, 6, 2201-2238, (2009)
[14] Chen, S.; Yeh, C., Evolving traders and the business school with genetic programming: a new architecture of the agent-based artificial stock market, J. Econ. Dyn. Control, 25, 363-393, (2001) · Zbl 0956.91037
[15] Choudhry, M., An introduction to value-at-risk, (2006), John Wiley & Sons Chichester
[16] Clegg, R., A practical guide to measuring the Hurst parameter, (21st UK Performance Engineering Workshop, School of Computing Science Technical Report Series, CSTR-916, Newcastle, (2006)), 43-55
[17] Colander, D., The risks of financial modeling: var and the economic meltdown, (2009), U.S. House of Representatives, Committee on Science and Technology, for the hearing
[18] Cont, R., Empirical properties of asset returns: stylized facts and statistical issues, Quant. Finance, 1, 223-236, (2001) · Zbl 1408.62174
[19] Cristelli, M., Complexity in financial markets, (2014), Springer
[20] Danielsson, J.; Shin, H., Endogenous risk., (2002)
[21] Danielsson, J.; Embrechts, P.; Goodhart, P.; Keating, C.; Muennich, F.; Renault, O., An Academic response to basel II, (2001), LSE Financial Markets Group.
[22] Danielsson, J.; Shin, H.; Zigrand, J., The impact of risk regulation on price dynamics, J. Bank. Finance, 28, 1069-1087, (2004)
[23] Danielsson, J.; Shin, H.; Zigrand, J., (Risk Appetite And Endogenous Risk, (2009))
[24] Davis, E., A reappraisal of market liquidity risk in the light of the Russia/LTCM global securities market crisis, (Workshop on “Empirical research on bank supervision and structure”, (1999), Basle Committee on Banking Supervision Amsterdam)
[25] De Grauwe, P.; Grimaldi, M., (Bubbles And Crashes In A Behavioural Finance Model, (2004), Sveriges Riksbank), working paper series No.164
[26] Duffy, J.; Ünver, U., Asset price bubbles and crashes with near-zero-intelligence traders, Econ. Theory, 537-563, (2006) · Zbl 1089.91044
[27] Financial stability review - June 2007, Frankfurt: European Central Bank, (2007)
[28] Einarsson, R., Reproducing the stylized facts of financial returns, (2013), Chalmers University of Technology Göteborg
[29] Faria, L., (Financial Regulation - Part II: Bank’s Behaviour Under Basel III Capital Requirements Using An Agent-Based Model, (2012)), Policy paper 12/19
[30] Faria, L.; Phelps, S., An investigation of the consequences of basel III using an agent-based model, (The 13th International Conference on Electronic Commerce., Liverpool, (2011))
[31] Farmer, J.; Joshi, S., The price dynamics of common trading strategies, J. Econ. Behav. Organ., 49, 149-171, (2002)
[32] Feridun, M., Failure of value at risk systems: a case study, Eur. J. Econ. Finance Admin. Sci., 2, 1, 57-67, (2005)
[33] Finger, C., Var is from Mars, capital is from venus, Res. Mon., (2009), RiskMetrics Group April 2009
[34] Fostel, A.; Geanakoplos, J., Leverage cycles and the anxious economy, Am. Econ. Rev., 98, 4, 1211-1244, (2008)
[35] Gadanecz, B.; Jayaram, K., Measures of financial stability - a review, IFC Bull., 31, (2008)
[36] Geanakoplos, J., Promises promises, (1997), Cowles Foundation New Haven, Paper N.1057
[37] Haldane, A.; May, R., Systemic risk in banking ecosystems, Nature, 469, 351-355, (2011)
[38] Hermsen, O., Does basel II destabilize financial markets? an agent-based financial market perspective, Eur. Phys. J. B, 73, 29-40, (2010)
[39] Hoelle, M., (The Effects Of Dependent Beliefs On Endogenous Leverage, (2016)) · Zbl 1415.91264
[40] Global financial stability report - October 2007, (2007), International Monetary Fund Washington D.C
[41] Johnson, N.; Jefferies, P.; Ming Hui, P., Financial market complexity, (2003), Oxford University Press New York
[42] Jorion, P., Value at risk: the new benchmark for managing financial risk, (2001), McGraw-Hill New York
[43] Jorion, P., Fallacies about the effects of market risk management systems, Financial Stability Review - December 2002, 115-127, (2002)
[44] Kestner, L., Quantitative trading strategies, (2003), McGraw-Hill New York
[45] Llacay, B., El impacto de las técnicas var en los mercados financieros. enfoque basado en la simulación multiagente, (2015), Universitat de Barcelona, Ph.D. Thesis
[46] Lux, T., Herd behaviour, bubbles and crashes, Econ. J., 105, 431, 881-896, (1995)
[47] Lux, T.; Marchesi, M., Volatility clustering in financial markets: a microsimulation of interacting agents, Int. J. Theor. Appl. Finance, 3, 4, 675-702, (2000) · Zbl 0967.91072
[48] MacKenzie, D., Long-term capital management and the sociology of arbitrage, Econ. Soc., 32, 349-380, (2003)
[49] Madhavan, A., Market microstructure: A survey, (2000), Marshall School of Business Los Angeles
[50] Malkiel, B., A random walk down wall street, (1973), Nueva York: Norton
[51] Manamperi, N., A comparative analysis of US financial stress indicators, (2013), Lubbock: Texas Tech University
[52] McNeil, A.; Frey, R.; Embrechts, P., Quantitative risk management: concepts, techniques, and tools, (2005), Princeton: Princeton University Press · Zbl 1089.91037
[53] Milton, A., Day trading with Donchian channels, (2016, June), The Balance, Retrieved February 20, 2017, from
[54] Morris, S.; Shin, H., Market risk with interdependent choice, (Conference on Liquidity Risk. Frankfurt, (2000))
[55] Murphy, J., Technical analysis of the financial markets, (1999), New York Institute of Finance Paramus
[56] O’Neill, B., Fundamentals of the stock market, (2011), McGraw-Hill
[57] Pericoli, M.; Sbracia, M., (Crowded trades among hedge funds, (2010)), Working paper
[58] Perold, A., Long-term capital management, L.P, (1999), Harvard Business School Publishing Boston
[59] Persaud, A., Sending the herd off the cliff edge: the disturbing interaction between herding and market-sensitive risk management practices, J. Risk Finance, 1-6, (2000), ERisk
[60] Peters, E., Stable vs. unstable markets: a tale of two states, First Quadrant, (2014)
[61] Rebonato, R., Plight of the fortune tellers: why we need to manage financial risk differently, (2007), Princeton: Princeton University Press · Zbl 1193.91005
[62] Saita, F., Value at risk and bank capital management, (2007), Academic Press San Diego
[63] Shin, H., Risk and liquidity, (2010), Oxford University Press Oxford
[64] Takahashi, H., Analyzing the influence of value at risk on financial markets through agent-based modeling, Int. J. Knowl.Based Intell. Eng. Syst., 17, 257-266, (2013)
[65] Tasca, P.; Battiston, S., (Market Procyclicality and Systemic Risk, (2012), ETH Risk Center Zurich), Working Paper ETH-RC-12-012
[66] Taylor, M., What Is sensitivity analysis?, 1-8, (2009), What is...? series
[67] Taylor, S., Asset price dynamics, volatility, and prediction, (2005), Princeton University Press Princeton
[68] ten Broeke, G.; van Voorn, G.; Ligtenberg, A., Which sensitivity analysis method should I use for my agent-based model?, J. Artif. Soc. Social Simul., 19, 1, (2016), DOI 0.18564/jasss.2857
[69] Global financial development report - financial stability, (2013), Retrieved May 24, 2013, from Key terms explained.
[70] Thurner, S., Systemic financial risk: agent based models to understand the leverage cycle on national scales and its consequences, OECD, (2011)
[71] Thurner, S.; Farmer, J.; Geanakoplos, J., Leverage causes fat tails and clustered volatility, Quant. Finance, 12, 5, 695-707, (2012) · Zbl 1278.91154
[72] Trichet, J., Intellectual challenges to financial stability analysis in the era of macroprudential oversight, Financ. Stab., (2011), Review No. 15 - Banque de France
[73] Tsay, R., Analysis of financial time series, (2005), John Wiley & Sons Hoboken. · Zbl 1086.91054
[74] Westerhoff, F., A simple agent-based financial market model: direct interactions and comparisons of trading profits, (BERG Working Paper Series On Government And Growth, No.61, (2009))
[75] Whitehead, C., Destructive coordination, Cornell Law Rev., 96, 323-364, (2013)
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. In some cases that data have been complemented/enhanced by data from zbMATH Open. This attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming completeness or a perfect matching.