×

Social contagion and the survival of diverse investment styles. (English) Zbl 1531.91226

Summary: We examine the contagion of investment ideas in a multiperiod setting in which investors are more likely to transmit their ideas to other investors after experiencing higher payoffs in one of two investment styles with different return distributions. We show that heterogeneous investment styles are able to coexist in the long run, implying a greater diversity than predicted by traditional theory. We characterize the survival and popularity of styles in relation to the distribution of security returns. In addition, we demonstrate that psychological effects such as conformist preference can lead to oscillations and bubbles in the choice of style. These results remain robust under a wide class of replication rules and endogenous returns. They offer empirically testable predictions, and provide new insights into the persistence of the wide range of investment strategies used by individual investors, hedge funds, and other professional portfolio managers.

MSC:

91G10 Portfolio theory
91G45 Financial networks (including contagion, systemic risk, regulation)

Software:

Adam
Full Text: DOI

References:

[1] Alchian, A. A., Uncertainty, evolution, and economic theory, J. Polit. Econ., 211-221 (1950)
[2] Almgren, R.; Thum, C.; Hauptmann, E.; Li, H., Direct estimation of equity market impact, Risk, 18, 58-62 (2005)
[3] Altshuler, Y.; Pan, W.; Pentland, A. S., Trends prediction using social diffusion models, (International Conference on Social Computing, Behavioral-Cultural Modeling, and Prediction (2012), Springer), 97-104
[4] Amir, R.; Belkov, S.; Evstigneev, I. V.; Hens, T., An evolutionary finance model with short selling and endogenous asset supply, Econ. Theory, 1-23 (2020)
[5] Amir, R.; Evstigneev, I. V.; Hens, T.; Potapova, V.; Schenk-Hoppé, K. R., Evolution in pecunia, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., 118 (2021)
[6] Amir, R.; Evstigneev, I. V.; Hens, T.; Schenk-Hoppé, K. R., Market selection and survival of investment strategies, J. Math. Econ., 41, 105-122 (2005) · Zbl 1118.91046
[7] Ammann, M.; Schaub, N., Do individual investors trade on investment-related Internet postings?, Manag. Sci., 67, 5679-5702 (2021)
[8] Ang, A.; Hodrick, R. J.; Xing, Y.; Zhang, X., The cross-section of volatility and expected returns, J. Finance, 61, 259-299 (2006)
[9] Ang, A.; Hodrick, R. J.; Xing, Y.; Zhang, X., High idiosyncratic volatility and low returns: international and further u.s. evidence, J. Financ. Econ., 91, 1-23 (2009)
[10] Anufriev, M.; Bottazzi, G., Market equilibria under procedural rationality, J. Math. Econ., 46, 1140-1172 (2010) · Zbl 1232.91264
[11] Anufriev, M.; Dindo, P., Wealth-driven selection in a financial market with heterogeneous agents, J. Econ. Behav. Organ., 73, 327-358 (2010)
[12] Argarwal, S.; Azar, P. D.; Lo, A. W.; Singh, T., Momentum, mean-reversion and social media: evidence from stocktwits and Twitter, J. Portf. Manag., 44, 7, 85-95 (2018)
[13] Bailey, M.; Cao, R.; Kuchler, T.; Stroebel, J., The economic effects of social networks: evidence from the housing market, J. Polit. Econ., 126, 2224-2276 (2018)
[14] Baker, M.; Bradley, B.; Wurgler, J., Benchmarks as limits to arbitrage: understanding the low-volatility anomaly, Financ. Anal. J., 67, 40-54 (2011)
[15] Bali, T. G.; Brown, S. J.; Caglayan, M. O., Do hedge funds’ exposures to risk factors predict their future returns?, J. Financ. Econ., 101, 36-68 (2011)
[16] Barber, B. M.; Huang, X.; Odean, T., Which factors matter to investors? Evidence from mutual fund flows, Rev. Financ. Stud., 29, 2600-2642 (2016)
[17] Barber, B. M.; Odean, T., All that glitters: the effect of attention and news on the buying behavior of individual and institutional investors, Rev. Financ. Stud., 21, 785-818 (2007)
[18] Barberis, N.; Shleifer, A., Style investing, J. Financ. Econ., 68, 161-199 (2003)
[19] Barberis, N.; Shleifer, A.; Vishny, R., A model of investor sentiment, J. Financ. Econ., 49, 307-343 (1998)
[20] Barucci, E.; Dindo, P.; Grassetti, F., Portfolio insurers and constant weight traders: who will survive?, Quant. Finance, 21, 1993-2004 (2021)
[21] Belkov, S.; Evstigneev, I. V.; Hens, T., An evolutionary finance model with a risk-free asset, Ann. Finance, 16, 593-607 (2020) · Zbl 1461.91268
[22] Belkov, S.; Evstigneev, I. V.; Hens, T.; Xu, L., Nash equilibrium strategies and survival portfolio rules in evolutionary models of asset markets, Math. Financ. Econ., 14, 249-262 (2020) · Zbl 1437.91046
[23] Berk, J. B.; Van Binsbergen, J. H., Assessing asset pricing models using revealed preference, J. Financ. Econ., 119, 1-23 (2016)
[24] Bertsimas, D.; Lo, A. W., Optimal control of execution costs, J. Financ. Mark., 1, 1-50 (1998)
[25] Biais, B.; Shadur, R., Darwinian selection does not eliminate irrational traders, Eur. Econ. Rev., 44, 469-490 (2000)
[26] Blume, L.; Easley, D., Evolution and market behavior, J. Econ. Theory, 58, 9-40 (1992) · Zbl 0769.90014
[27] Blume, L.; Easley, D., If you’re so smart, why aren’t you rich? Belief selection in complete and incomplete markets, Econometrica, 74, 929-966 (2006) · Zbl 1151.91639
[28] Bottazzi, G.; Dindo, P., Evolution and market behavior with endogenous investment rules, J. Econ. Dyn. Control, 48, 121-146 (2014) · Zbl 1402.91938
[29] Bottazzi, G.; Dindo, P.; Giachini, D., Long-run heterogeneity in an exchange economy with fixed-mix traders, Econ. Theory, 66, 407-447 (2018) · Zbl 1416.91306
[30] Boyd, R.; Richerson, P. J., Culture and the Evolutionary Process (1985), University of Chicago Press: University of Chicago Press Chicago, IL
[31] Boyson, N. M.; Stahel, C. W.; Stulz, R. M., Hedge fund contagion and liquidity shocks, J. Finance, 65, 1789-1816 (2010)
[32] Brennan, T. J.; Lo, A. W., The origin of behavior, Q. J. Finance, 1, 55-108 (2011)
[33] Brennan, T. J.; Lo, A. W.; Zhang, R., Variety is the spice of life: irrational behavior as adaptation to stochastic environments, Q. J. Finance, 8, Article 1850009 pp. (2018)
[34] Brock, W. A.; Hommes, C. H., A rational route to randomness, Econometrica, 1059-1095 (1997) · Zbl 0898.90042
[35] Brock, W. A.; Hommes, C. H., Heterogeneous beliefs and routes to chaos in a simple asset pricing model, J. Econ. Dyn. Control, 22, 1235-1274 (1998) · Zbl 0913.90042
[36] Brown, J. R.; Ivković, Z.; Smith, P. A.; Weisbenner, S., Neighbors matter: causal community effects and stock market participation, J. Finance, 63, 1509-1531 (2008)
[37] Burnside, C.; Eichenbaum, M.; Rebelo, S., Understanding booms and busts in housing markets, J. Polit. Econ., 124, 1088-1147 (2016)
[38] Chan, N.; Getmansky, M.; Haas, S. M.; Lo, A. W., Do hedge funds increase systemic risk?, Econ. Rev.- Fed. Reserve Bank Atlanta, 91, 49 (2006)
[39] Chiarella, C.; Dieci, R.; He, X.-Z., Heterogeneity, market mechanisms, and asset price dynamics, (Hens, T.; Schenk-Hoppé, K. R., Handbook of Financial Markets: Dynamics and Evolution (2009), Elsevier), 277-344
[40] Chinco, A., The ex ante likelihood of bubbles, Manag. Sci., 69, 2, 1222-1244 (2023)
[41] Cohen, L.; Frazzini, A.; Malloy, C., The small world of investing: board connections and mutual fund returns, J. Polit. Econ., 116, 951-979 (2008)
[42] Cookson, J. A.; Niessner, M., Why don’t we agree? Evidence from a social network of investors, J. Finance, 75, 173-228 (2020)
[43] Cooper, W. S.; Kaplan, R. H., Adaptive “coin-flipping”: a decision-theoretic examination of natural selection for random individual variation, J. Theor. Biol., 94, 135-151 (1982)
[44] Cronqvist, H.; Siegel, S.; Yu, F., Value versus growth investing: why do different investors have different styles?, J. Financ. Econ., 117, 333-349 (2015)
[45] Cvitanić, J.; Malamud, S., Price impact and portfolio impact, J. Financ. Econ., 100, 201-225 (2011)
[46] Da, Z.; Engelberg, J.; Gao, P., In search of attention, J. Finance, 66, 1461-1499 (2011)
[47] De Long, J. B.; Shleifer, A.; Summers, L. H.; Waldmann, R. J., Noise trader risk in financial markets, J. Polit. Econ., 98, 703-738 (1990)
[48] De Long, J. B.; Shleifer, A.; Summers, L. H.; Waldmann, R. J., The survival of noise traders in financial markets, J. Bus., 64, 1-19 (1991)
[49] DeGroot, M. H., Reaching a consensus, J. Am. Stat. Assoc., 69, 118-121 (1974) · Zbl 0282.92011
[50] Dieci, R.; He, X.-Z., Heterogeneous agent models in finance, (Handbook of Computational Economics, vol. 4 (2018)), 257-328
[51] Dindo, P., Survival in speculative markets, J. Econ. Theory, 181, 1-43 (2019) · Zbl 1411.91495
[52] Easley, D.; Yang, L., Loss aversion, survival and asset prices, J. Econ. Theory, 160, 494-516 (2015) · Zbl 1369.91058
[53] Evstigneev, I.; Hens, T.; Potapova, V.; Schenk-Hoppé, K. R., Behavioral equilibrium and evolutionary dynamics in asset markets, J. Math. Econ., 91, 121-135 (2020) · Zbl 1457.91235
[54] Evstigneev, I. V.; Hens, T.; Schenk-Hoppé, K. R., Market selection of financial trading strategies: global stability, Math. Finance, 12, 329-339 (2002) · Zbl 1047.91030
[55] Evstigneev, I. V.; Hens, T.; Schenk-Hoppé, K. R., Evolutionary stable stock markets, Econ. Theory, 27, 449-468 (2006) · Zbl 1086.91027
[56] Evstigneev, I. V.; Hens, T.; Schenk-Hoppé, K. R., Globally evolutionarily stable portfolio rules, J. Econ. Theory, 140, 197-228 (2008) · Zbl 1136.91429
[57] Fama, E. F., The behavior of stock-market prices, J. Bus., 34-105 (1965)
[58] Fama, E. F., Efficient capital markets: a review of theory and empirical work, J. Finance, 25, 383-417 (1970)
[59] Fama, E. F., Two pillars of asset pricing, Am. Econ. Rev., 104, 1467-1485 (2014)
[60] Farmer, J. D.; Joshi, S., The price dynamics of common trading strategies, J. Econ. Behav. Organ., 49, 149-171 (2002)
[61] Ferri, R. A., The ETF Book: All You Need to Know About Exchange-Traded Funds (2011), John Wiley & Sons: John Wiley & Sons Hoboken, NJ
[62] Frank, S. A., Natural selection. I. Variable environments and uncertain returns on investment, J. Evol. Biol., 24, 2299-2309 (2011)
[63] Frank, S. A.; Slatkin, M., Evolution in a variable environment, Am. Nat., 136, 244-260 (1990)
[64] Frazzini, A.; Pedersen, L. H., Betting against beta, J. Financ. Econ., 111, 1-25 (2014)
[65] Friedman, M., Essays in Positive Economics, vol. 231 (1953), University of Chicago Press: University of Chicago Press Chicago, IL
[66] Froot, K.; Teo, M., Style investing and institutional investors, J. Financ. Quant. Anal., 43, 883-906 (2008)
[67] Fung, W.; Hsieh, D. A., Hedge fund benchmarks: a risk-based approach, Financ. Anal. J., 60, 65-80 (2004)
[68] Getmansky, M.; Lee, P. A.; Lo, A. W., Hedge funds: a dynamic industry in transition, Annu. Rev. Financ. Econ., 7, 483-577 (2015)
[69] Greenwood, R.; Shleifer, A.; You, Y., Bubbles for Fama, J. Financ. Econ., 131, 20-43 (2019)
[70] Han, B.; Hirshleifer, D.; Walden, J., Social transmission bias and investor behavior, J. Financ. Quant. Anal., 57, 390-412 (2022)
[71] Han, B.; Yang, L., Social networks, information acquisition, and asset prices, Manag. Sci., 59, 1444-1457 (2013)
[72] Hasanhodzic, J.; Lo, A. W., Can hedge-fund returns be replicated?: the linear case, J. Invest. Manag., 5, 5-45 (2006)
[73] Henderson, B. J.; Pearson, N. D., The dark side of financial innovation: a case study of the pricing of a retail financial product, J. Financ. Econ., 100, 227-247 (2011)
[74] Hens, T.; Schenk-Hoppé, K. R., Patience is a virtue: in value investing, Int. Rev. Finance, 20, 1019-1031 (2020)
[75] Hens, T.; Schenk-Hoppé, K. R., Evolutionary stability of portfolio rules in incomplete markets, J. Math. Econ., 41, 43-66 (2005) · Zbl 1118.91050
[76] Hens, T.; Schenk-Hoppé, K. R., Handbook of Financial Markets: Dynamics and Evolution (2009), Elsevier
[77] Hirshleifer, D., Presidential address: social transmission bias in economics and finance, J. Finance (2020)
[78] Hirshleifer, D.; Luo, G. Y., On the survival of overconfident traders in a competitive securities market, J. Financ. Mark., 4, 73-84 (2001)
[79] Hirshleifer, D.; Subrahmanyam, A.; Titman, S., Feedback and the success of irrational investors, J. Financ. Econ., 81, 311-338 (2006)
[80] Hirshleifer, D.; Teoh, S. H., Thought and behavior contagion in capital markets, (Hens, T.; Schenk-Hoppé, K. R., Handbook of Financial Markets: Dynamics and Evolution (2009), Elsevier), 1-46
[81] Holtfort, T., From standard to evolutionary finance: a literature survey, Manag. Rev. Q., 69, 207-232 (2019)
[82] Hommes, C.; Wagener, F., Complex evolutionary systems in behavioral finance, (Hens, T.; Schenk-Hoppé, K. R., Handbook of Financial Markets: Dynamics and Evolution (2009), Elsevier), 217-276
[83] Hommes, C. H., Heterogeneous agent models in economics and finance, (Handbook of Computational Economics, vol. 2 (2006)), 1109-1186
[84] Hong, H.; Kubik, J. D.; Stein, J. C., Social interaction and stock-market participation, J. Finance, 59, 137-163 (2004)
[85] Hong, H.; Kubik, J. D.; Stein, J. C., Thy neighbor’s portfolio: word-of-mouth effects in the holdings and trades of money managers, J. Finance, 60, 2801-2824 (2005)
[86] Hong, H.; Stein, J. C.; Yu, J., Simple forecasts and paradigm shifts, J. Finance, 62, 1207-1242 (2007)
[87] Ivković, Z.; Weisbenner, S., Information diffusion effects in individual investors’ common stock purchases: covet thy neighbors’ investment choices, Rev. Financ. Stud., 20, 1327-1357 (2007)
[88] Kaustia, M.; Knüpfer, S., Peer performance and stock market entry, J. Financ. Econ., 104, 321-338 (2012)
[89] Kingma, D. P.; Ba, J., Adam: a method for stochastic optimization, (International Conference on Learning Representations (ICLR) (2015))
[90] Kirman, A., Epidemics of opinion and speculative bubbles in financial markets, (Taylor, M., Money and Financial Markets (1991), Macmillan: Macmillan London), 354-368
[91] Kirman, A., Ants, rationality, and recruitment, Q. J. Econ., 108, 137-156 (1993)
[92] Klick, J.; Parisi, F., Social networks, self-denial, and median preferences: conformity as an evolutionary strategy, J. Socio-Econ., 37, 1319-1327 (2008)
[93] Kogan, L.; Ross, S. A.; Wang, J.; Westerfield, M. M., The price impact and survival of irrational traders, J. Finance, 61, 195-229 (2006)
[94] Kogan, L.; Ross, S. A.; Wang, J.; Westerfield, M. M., Market selection, J. Econ. Theory, 168, 209-236 (2017) · Zbl 1400.91204
[95] Kuchler, T.; Li, Y.; Peng, L.; Stroebel, J.; Zhou, D., Social proximity to capital: implications for investors and firms, Rev. Financ. Stud., 35, 2743-2789 (2022)
[96] Kuchler, T.; Stroebel, J., Social finance, Annu. Rev. Financ. Econ., 13, 37-55 (2021)
[97] Kumar, A., Dynamic style preferences of individual investors and stock returns, J. Financ. Quant. Anal., 44, 607-640 (2009)
[98] Kyle, A.; Wang, F. A., Speculation duopoly with agreement to disagree: can overconfidence survive the market test?, J. Finance, 52, 2073-2090 (1997)
[99] Kyle, A. S., Continuous auctions and insider trading, Econometrica, 53, 1315-1335 (1985) · Zbl 0571.90010
[100] LeBaron, B., Agent-based computational finance: suggested readings and early research, J. Econ. Dyn. Control, 24, 679-702 (2000) · Zbl 0945.91018
[101] LeBaron, B., A builder’s guide to agent-based financial markets, Quant. Finance, 1, 254 (2001)
[102] LeBaron, B., Agent-based computational finance, (Handbook of Computational Economics, vol. 2 (2006)), 1187-1233
[103] Lensberg, T., Investment behavior under knightian uncertainty-an evolutionary approach, J. Econ. Dyn. Control, 23, 1587-1604 (1999) · Zbl 1005.91060
[104] Lensberg, T.; Schenk-Hoppé, K. R., On the evolution of investment strategies and the kelly rule? A darwinian approach, Rev. Finance, 11, 25-50 (2007) · Zbl 1183.91199
[105] Lettau, M.; Ludvigson, S. C.; Manoel, P., Characteristics of mutual fund portfolios: Where are the value funds? (2018), NBER Working Paper No. w25381
[106] Lettau, M.; Madhavan, A., Exchange-traded funds 101 for economists, J. Econ. Perspect., 32, 135-154 (2018)
[107] Levin, S. A.; Lo, A. W., Introduction to pnas special issue on evolutionary models of financial markets, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., 118 (2021)
[108] Li, J.; Yu, J., Investor attention, psychological anchors, and stock return predictability, J. Financ. Econ., 104, 401-419 (2012)
[109] Lillo, F.; Farmer, J. D.; Mantegna, R. N., Master curve for price-impact function, Nature, 421, 129-130 (2003)
[110] Lo, A. W., The adaptive markets hypothesis, J. Portf. Manag., 30, 15-29 (2004)
[111] Lo, A. W., Hedge Funds: An Analytic Perspective (2008), Princeton University Press: Princeton University Press Princeton, NJ · Zbl 1151.91003
[112] Lo, A. W., Adaptive Markets: Financial Evolution at the Speed of Thought (2017), Princeton University Press: Princeton University Press Princeton, NJ
[113] Lo, A. W.; Marlowe, K. P.; Zhang, R., To maximize or randomize? An experimental study of probability matching in financial decision making, PLoS ONE, 16, Article e0252540 pp. (2021)
[114] Lo, A. W.; Zhang, R., The evolutionary origin of bayesian heuristics and finite memory, iScience, 24, Article 102853 pp. (2021)
[115] Lux, T., Herd behaviour, bubbles and crashes, Econ. J., 881-896 (1995)
[116] Lux, T., Stochastic behavioral asset-pricing models and the stylized facts, (Hens, T.; Schenk-Hoppé, K. R., Handbook of Financial Markets: Dynamics and Evolution (2009), Elsevier), 161-215
[117] Lux, T.; Marchesi, M., Volatility clustering in financial markets: a microsimulation of interacting agents, Int. J. Theor. Appl. Finance, 3, 675-702 (2000) · Zbl 0967.91072
[118] Lux, T.; Zwinkels, R. C., Empirical validation of agent-based models, (Hommes, C.; LeBaron, B., Handbook of Computational Economics, vol. 4 (2018), Elsevier), 437-488
[119] Merton, R. C., An analytic derivation of the efficient portfolio frontier, J. Financ. Quant. Anal., 7, 1851-1872 (1972)
[120] Merton, R. C., An intertemporal capital asset pricing model, Econometrica, 867-887 (1973) · Zbl 0283.90003
[121] Moran, P. A.P., Random Processes in Genetics, Mathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society, vol. 54, 60-71 (1958), Cambridge University Press · Zbl 0091.15701
[122] Ozsoylev, H. N.; Walden, J.; Yavuz, M. D.; Bildik, R., Investor networks in the stock market, Rev. Financ. Stud., 27, 1323-1366 (2014)
[123] Palczewski, J.; Schenk-Hoppé, K. R.; Wang, T., Itchy feet vs cool heads: flow of funds in an agent-based financial market, J. Econ. Dyn. Control, 63, 53-68 (2016) · Zbl 1401.91593
[124] Pan, W.; Altshuler, Y.; Pentland, A., Decoding social influence and the wisdom of the crowd in financial trading network, (Privacy, Security, Risk and Trust (PASSAT), 2012 International Conference on and 2012 International Conference on Social Computing (SocialCom) (2012), IEEE), 203-209
[125] Pedersen, L. H., Game on: social networks and markets, J. Financ. Econ. (2022)
[126] Penrose, E. T., Biological analogies in the theory of the firm, Am. Econ. Rev., 804-819 (1952)
[127] Pentland, A., Social Physics: How Social Networks Can Make Us Smarter (2015), Penguin: Penguin New York, NY
[128] Pool, V. K.; Stoffman, N.; Yonker, S. E., The people in your neighborhood: social interactions and mutual fund portfolios, J. Finance, 70, 2679-2732 (2015)
[129] Robson, A. J., A biological basis for expected and non-expected utility, J. Econ. Theory, 68, 397-424 (1996) · Zbl 0852.90019
[130] Samuelson, P. A., Proof that properly anticipated prices fluctuate randomly, Ind. Manage. Rev., 6, 41-49 (1965)
[131] Sandroni, A., Do markets favor agents able to make accurate predictions?, Econometrica, 68, 1303-1341 (2000) · Zbl 1055.91539
[132] Sandroni, A., Market selection when markets are incomplete, J. Math. Econ., 41, 91-104 (2005) · Zbl 1118.91062
[133] Scholl, M. P.; Calinescu, A.; Farmer, J. D., How market ecology explains market malfunction, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., 118, Article e2015574118 pp. (2021)
[134] Sharpe, W., Capital asset prices: a theory of market equilibrium under conditions of risk, J. Finance, 19, 425-442 (1964)
[135] Shiller, R. J., Irrational Exuberance (2000), Princeton University Press: Princeton University Press Princeton, New Jersey
[136] Shiller, R. J., Narrative economics, Am. Econ. Rev., 107, 967-1004 (2017)
[137] Teo, M.; Woo, S.-J., Style effects in the cross-section of stock returns, J. Financ. Econ., 74, 367-398 (2004)
[138] Topol, R., Bubbles and volatility of stock prices: effect of mimetic contagion, Econ. J., 101, 786-800 (1991)
[139] Wahal, S.; Yavuz, M. D., Style investing, comovement and return predictability, J. Financ. Econ., 107, 136-154 (2013)
[140] Yan, H., Natural selection in financial markets: does it work?, Manag. Sci., 54, 1935-1950 (2008) · Zbl 1232.91468
[141] Zhang, R.; Brennan, T. J.; Lo, A. W., The origin of risk aversion, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., 111, 17777-17782 (2014)
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. In some cases that data have been complemented/enhanced by data from zbMATH Open. This attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming completeness or a perfect matching.