I, Robot

An effective and self-aware hit with a light philosophical undertone. In other words, one of the few smart, eye-candy popcorn movies of the new millennium. That has to be appreciated, whether the topic is your cup of tea or not. Still, it is a class lower than Minority Report. (12/26/2004)

I saw the film as a hot new release in the movie theater in 2004 and was absolutely thrilled by it. As a sci-fi lover, I must always stand by the fact that the film has a concept, and by using Asimov's laws, it highlights the classic problem associated with robots. How far can we go with AI before it turns on us? The ending is a bit rough, but otherwise, it's an excellent action ride with a good detective plot, and considering the film is already 10 years old, it has great special effects sequences. (12/20/2013)

I, Robot is a spectacular, technically flawless action flick for mainstream popcorn fans, but even more discerning viewers will enjoy it. But any talk of highly intelligent entertainment in the mold of Minority Report is out of line. The film’s screenplay is simple and unsophisticated, with banal dialogue and a sizable portion of clichés. The screenplay is brought up to the level of high-quality entertainment only by director Alex Proyas, thanks to whom the result is dynamic enough not to be boring, and paranoid and disturbing enough to be enthralling. (09/13/2004)

If it weren't so excessively cool, it would be the biggest sci-fi event since the launch of Spielberg's Minority Report. Directed by Alex Proyas, the film has a suggestive atmosphere and, surprisingly, a decent (albeit reduced) idea. Will Smith was cast to ensure commercial security, so his Del Spooner makes the film a bit of a macho zodiac. I don't mind the character as a whole, but some of the one-liners seem as natural in the context of the story as Zarathustra in public toilets. Nevertheless, I pay tribute to Proyas for the ease with which he was able to balance the compromise between the action show and the impressive sci-fi spectacle with a warning undertone... How easily he was able to incorporate impressive emotions and sequences worth remembering into the veins of the film. In the end, one tends to forgive even the several exaggerated fancy "matrix-like" scenes, and if you are not one of the uncompromising fans of Isaac Asimov, then with a bit of good will, you won’t be able to help but enjoy this perfectly filmed ride. Definitely a hot candidate for sci-fi of the year. (09/03/2004)

I really like Will Smith, and I, Robot is among my favorite films. Movies about robots and artificial intelligence have always interested me. Here, the director plays with the idea of what it would be like if, in a few decades, we encountered robots on the street who would serve humans devotedly. Will Smith delivers an excellent performance, as always, and he’s supported by witty one-liners. Given that the film is already twelve years old, it features masterfully crafted action scenes that took my breath away at times. The story is also good and well-thought-out. There’s nothing to debate, and it deserves 90%. (04/11/2016)